Cultus Vitae | Retirement Series, Part 3
In the first article, we asked how you know whether you have enough to retire. In the second, we asked what you would actually do with that retirement.
Now let’s put the two together. Could looking at how your income and expenses change over time allow you to do more with the money you have?
Suppose you and your spouse want to retire at 60. For simplicity, let’s assume you are both the same age. You have $2.5 million invested and expect to spend $100,000 a year.
Using 4% as a starting withdrawal calculation:
$2.5 million × 4% = $100,000 a year.
You might conclude that $100,000 is your retirement budget. But before we settle on that, does your portfolio need to provide the same amount every year? What happens when health insurance costs change, Social Security begins, or your mortgage ends?
Let’s work through those changes and see what they could allow you to do.
For this example, we will leave out income taxes and inflation and assume investments earn a steady 4% a year after fees. Before making a spending recommendation, we would need to include taxes, rising prices, and years when investments do poorly.
Could you add $40,000 of travel to your retirement budget?
Start with healthcare
Suppose you are paying $3,000 a month for health insurance for the two of you. At 65, you both move to Medicare, and we estimate your combined insurance costs will fall to $1,000 a month.
Those are assumptions for this example, not quoted rates. We are holding other medical expenses unchanged. Actual premiums and out-of-pocket costs depend on your coverage and the care you use.
That is $2,000 less each month, or $24,000 less each year.
The lifestyle that cost $100,000 before 65 would now cost $76,000. You have not cut back on anything. Your insurance simply costs less.
Using the same 4% calculation:
$76,000 ÷ 4% = $1.9 million.
Under that calculation, a $1.9 million portfolio would support an initial $76,000 withdrawal at a 4% rate. That is $600,000 less than your starting balance, but it does not automatically mean you have $600,000 available to spend.
It gives us a reason to ask: Could you use some of that difference before you reach 65?
Let’s add $20,000 a year for travel
Instead of spending $100,000 a year beginning at 60, suppose you spend $120,000. The additional $20,000 goes toward trips you and your spouse have wanted to take.
Assuming your investments earn 4% each year, withdrawing $120,000 annually for five years would leave you with approximately $2.39 million at 65.
You have spent an additional $100,000 on travel over those five years. Your portfolio has declined a little, but now the insurance savings begin.
What does it take to continue the same spending, including the additional travel?
$120,000 − $24,000 = $96,000 a year.
That $96,000 is almost exactly 4% of your remaining portfolio.
In this example, you took the trips before 65, spent down some of your savings, and arrived at 65 needing about 4% of the remaining balance for that year’s spending.
We looked ahead at the lower insurance cost and worked backward to see what you could do at 60.
But wait—what happens at 67?
Suppose you and your spouse each qualify for $3,500 a month in Social Security at 67, based on your own work records. Together, that is $84,000 a year before taxes and deductions.
Your annual spending, including the additional travel, is $96,000. How much would you now need from investments, before accounting for income taxes?
$96,000 − $84,000 = $12,000 a year.
That changes the picture again. Your portfolio had to provide all your spending in the early years. Once Social Security begins, it has much less to cover.
Knowing those checks are coming, could we plan for another $20,000 of travel from the beginning?
Now let’s try $40,000 more for travel
We go back to age 60 and revise the plan. Instead of adding $20,000 to the original budget, we add a total of $40,000.
Your starting budget becomes $140,000 a year. At 65, lower insurance costs bring it down to $116,000, with all the additional travel still included. At 67, Social Security begins paying for most of that spending.
Here is the revised plan. All amounts are annual, and income taxes have not yet been included.
| Your age | Household spending | Social Security income | Amount needed from investments |
| 60–64 | $140,000 | $0 | $140,000 |
| 65–66 | $116,000 | $0 | $116,000 |
| 67, when benefits begin | $116,000 | $84,000 | $32,000 |
Using the same 4% annual investment return, you would reach 67 with approximately $2.23 million invested.
Over those seven years, you have spent an additional $280,000 on travel. Yet the amount you need from investments has now fallen to $32,000 a year, before income taxes.
We started with a $100,000 budget. Looking at healthcare gave us a reason to test another $20,000 for travel. Looking at Social Security gave us a reason to test another $20,000.
We did not assume better investment returns; all we did was take into account when our financial picture would change.
And what happens when the mortgage ends?
Suppose your mortgage is scheduled to be paid off at 70. Its $1,500 monthly loan payment is already included in the budget.
That is another $18,000 a year you would no longer need to spend. Annual spending could fall from $116,000 to $98,000, while keeping the extra travel. With $84,000 coming from Social Security, investments would need to provide $14,000, before income taxes.
You would still have property taxes, insurance, and upkeep. But the loan payment is gone. You could leave that former payment invested or use some of it for something else.
Again, knowing what happens later may change what you decide to do earlier.
The same thinking can work in reverse
So far, expenses have gone down and income has gone up. Later, care needs could push spending in the other direction.
You might first need a few hours of help at home. Later, you might need daily assistance or care in a facility. The amount of help, its cost, and how long you need it can change. There is no single timetable everyone follows.
We should look at those possible stages, too. What might each one cost? What would insurance cover? What would need to come from your savings?
At the same time, you might be traveling less. Some money previously spent on trips could become available for care. We should account for both changes, rather than automatically adding every new care expense to the old budget. Those travel savings may cover only part of the care bill, and we still need to leave enough for the spouse who may be living independently.
When might it make sense to wait until 70 to collect Social Security?
For someone whose full retirement age is 67, waiting until 70 increases their own monthly Social Security retirement benefit by 24%, before cost-of-living adjustments. But in our example, the portfolio would have to cover three more years without those checks.
For a household without long-term care insurance, or enough savings to comfortably pay for care, I would examine whether that larger monthly benefit could help later. Medicare generally does not pay for long-term custodial care, such as ongoing help with bathing and dressing.
A larger Social Security check would not replace care insurance. But it could pay part of a future care bill and reduce what needs to come from savings. We would compare that benefit with the cost of waiting, your health, and whether you can comfortably fund those earlier years.
That is why we need the whole picture before deciding how much to spend. Some future changes may allow more travel now. Others may give us a reason to keep more in reserve.
Other ways to save and costs we need to watch
So far, we have looked at when income begins and when expenses change. Now we need to look at what happens on the tax return.
Our example has not yet included income taxes. The amount you withdraw is not necessarily the amount you have left to spend. Traditional IRA withdrawals are generally taxable to the extent the money has not already been taxed, and part of your Social Security benefits may also be taxable. Which accounts provide the money, and what other income you have, can change the result.
Medicare: Could a withdrawal increase your premiums?
Medicare Part B and prescription drug premiums can move higher when your income exceeds certain limits. This extra charge is called IRMAA. It generally looks at income from two years earlier. That means a large taxable withdrawal in the year you turn 63 could affect what you pay for Medicare in the year you turn 65.
Before taking additional money from a retirement account, we should check both the income tax and the possible increase in premiums.
Medicare generally uses your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI), which, for this purpose, is your adjusted gross income plus tax-exempt interest. Your standard deduction and itemized deductions do not reduce that figure. So staying within a particular income-tax bracket does not necessarily keep you below a Medicare income limit.
Sometimes paying higher premiums for a year may be worthwhile because another planning decision saves more over time. Sometimes spreading withdrawals over several years may be better. We will want to compare those choices before making the withdrawal.
Charity: Could you give the same amount at a lower after-tax cost?
Suppose charitable giving is already part of your budget. Instead of automatically writing a check, we should look at what you own.
You may have stock in a regular investment account that has increased in value and that you have held for more than a year. Giving those shares directly to a qualifying public charity generally avoids realizing the gain from selling them. If you itemize, the gift may also provide a deduction based on the shares’ current value, subject to the deduction rules and limits for that year.
We could also consider putting several years of planned giving into a donor-advised fund—an account held by a charitable organization. You make the gift now and recommend payments to charities over time. Grouping gifts this way may make the deduction more useful in the year you contribute. The money is permanently committed to charity, not available for your future spending.
But a charitable itemized deduction generally does not reduce the income Medicare uses for IRMAA. A gift that reduces your income tax may not reduce your Medicare premiums.
There is another option once you are 70½ or older. A qualifying gift sent directly from your IRA to an eligible charity can be excluded from your income and can count toward your required IRA withdrawals. This is called a qualified charitable distribution. Subject to its limits and rules, it can help control the income Medicare counts because the qualifying withdrawal stays out of your income in the first place.
That IRA gift cannot go to a donor-advised fund, and you cannot also claim a charitable deduction for the amount excluded from income.
We are looking at giving you already intend to do and asking whether a different way of funding it would leave more money available for your own needs.
Required withdrawals and Roth conversions: When should you pay the tax?
Return to the couple in our example. Once Social Security begins, they need much less from investments.
But suppose most of their savings are in traditional IRAs. Later, the government will require annual withdrawals from those accounts, even when they do not need the money for spending. These are called required minimum distributions, or RMDs.
Could paying some tax earlier reduce what they pay later?
One option is a Roth conversion: moving money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. You pay tax on the previously untaxed amount you move. Later withdrawals can be tax-free when the Roth withdrawal rules are met, and the original owner does not have to take annual required withdrawals from a Roth IRA.
Before recommending a conversion, I want to compare the tax cost now with what we expect later. Would smaller conversions over several years help? Where would the money to pay the tax come from? Would the conversion increase Medicare premiums?
Once required withdrawals begin, we also need to satisfy those requirements. The required withdrawal itself cannot be converted to a Roth.
Before 65, additional taxable income can also reduce income-based help with the cost of Marketplace health insurance. That belongs in the calculation, too.
The goal is not necessarily the lowest tax bill this year. It is to keep the overall tax cost of funding your retirement as low as reasonably possible.
Or, put another way, we want to consider your tax burden over your lifetime; not simply try to stay in the lowest bracket this year.
What does this change for you?
Are you starting to see why taxes and financial planning need to work so closely together?
In our example, we did not stop at “You have $2.5 million, so you can spend $100,000.” We looked at what the household would need at 60, 65, 67, and beyond. That gave us a reason to test spending more in the early years.
Then we looked at what could change the answer: future care, taxes, Medicare premiums, and how we use the retirement accounts.
The result might be more travel. It might be an earlier retirement, help for your children, or a larger reserve. It might also show that you need to spend less than you hoped.
Before telling you to work another year or give up something you have been looking forward to, I want to work through those choices.
Your first year of retirement is one year. Let’s not use it as the budget for all the years that follow.
—Mike
Notes on the example
These are hypothetical calculations, not a recommended spending plan. They assume both spouses retire at 60 with $2.5 million, investments earn a constant 4% annually after investment fees, and withdrawals occur at each year-end. Income taxes, inflation, Social Security cost-of-living increases, and unexpected expenses are excluded. The $20,000 and $40,000 travel increases are two alternative plans, each beginning at 60.
The insurance figures are assumed combined household premiums, not quoted Medicare rates or a family Medicare policy. Other medical expenses are held unchanged. Actual premiums and out-of-pocket costs vary.
Social Security amounts are assumed benefits before taxes and premium deductions. Because insurance premiums are already included in household spending, they are not also subtracted from the benefits in the example. Actual benefit estimates should reflect stopping work at 60, rather than assuming earnings continue until 67.
The mortgage ends through scheduled payments; paying it off early from savings would require a separate calculation.
Dividing spending by 4% does not establish that a portfolio will last. A constant 4% investment return is not the same as a sustainable withdrawal strategy. Before using a plan like this, we would test rising prices, taxes, uneven investment returns, a long retirement, and care expenses.
We would also plan for the loss of one spouse’s Social Security income: the survivor generally receives the higher applicable benefit, not both full payments.